Let’s talk about the elephant in the room – overtourism is creeping across North America like nobody’s business. We’ve all seen the Instagram posts of bumper-to-bumper traffic in US national parks and hour-long waits for that “candid” photo spot. While Europe and Asia have been grabbing headlines for tourist protests and entry fees, several North American destinations are quietly reaching their breaking point.
Before you finalize your 2025 travel plans, we’ve put together a list of five North American destinations that are dangerously close to joining Fodor’s infamous “No List.” These places aren’t ruined yet, but they’re showing all the warning signs of overtourism: environmental strain, local frustration, infrastructure collapse, and skyrocketing prices.
But don’t worry – we’re not just here to rain on your vacation parade. For each overcrowded hotspot, we’ll suggest an amazing alternative that delivers similar vibes without the crushing crowds. Let’s dive in!
1. Sedona, Arizona: Red Rocks, Traffic Jams, and Overwhelmed Trails
Sedona’s stunning red rock formations and supposed energy vortexes have made it an Instagram darling and spiritual seekers’ paradise. But this small desert town of just 10,000 residents now welcomes over 3 million visitors annually – and it’s showing.
The explosion of short-term rentals has turned many neighborhoods into ghost towns of vacation properties, driving housing costs through the roof for locals. The average home price in Sedona has increased by over 70% since 2019, pushing out the very people who give the town its character.
More concerning are the environmental impacts. Popular hiking trails like Cathedral Rock and Devil’s Bridge now resemble theme park lines during peak hours, with wait times exceeding 45 minutes just to snap a photo. Trail erosion, garbage, and unauthorized off-trail hiking are threatening the fragile desert ecosystem.
The city has implemented some measures – a shuttle system, increased parking fees, and trail reservation systems – but locals worry it’s too little, too late.
Where to go instead
Consider Flagstaff, just an hour north. You’ll find similar red rock terrain but with significantly fewer crowds. The nearby Coconino National Forest offers spectacular hiking, including the San Francisco Peaks. Flagstaff also boasts a more authentic Arizona vibe, excellent dining options, and proximity to the Grand Canyon. For a truly off-the-beaten-path alternative, check out Silver City, New Mexico, which offers spectacular desert landscapes, artist communities, and the Gila Wilderness without the crowds.
2. Tofino, British Columbia: The Surf Town at Capacity
This former fishing village on Vancouver Island’s rugged west coast has transformed into Canada’s premier surf destination. With its stunning beaches, ancient rainforests, and impressive food scene, Tofino has become a victim of its own success.
The town’s year-round population of about 2,000 can swell to over 20,000 during peak summer months. This influx has led to serious infrastructure issues – water shortages, sewage treatment concerns, and traffic congestion on the single winding road that connects Tofino to the rest of Vancouver Island.
Housing affordability has reached crisis levels. Many service industry workers who support the tourism economy can’t afford to live in Tofino, forcing long commutes or shared accommodations. The average home price has more than doubled in five years, with many properties converted to vacation rentals.
Most concerning is the impact on nearby Pacific Rim National Park Reserve, where crowding is affecting wildlife habitats and threatening the very wilderness experience visitors seek.
Where to go instead
Head to Ucluelet, just 40 minutes from Tofino but worlds away in terms of crowds. This working harbor town offers similar wild coastline views, excellent surfing opportunities, and access to the Wild Pacific Trail without the crushing tourism pressure. For something completely different but equally stunning, consider Haida Gwaii (formerly Queen Charlotte Islands) in northern British Columbia – an archipelago with pristine beaches, ancient indigenous culture, and a true wilderness experience.
3. Lake Tahoe, California/Nevada: Clear Waters Under Threat
Straddling the California-Nevada border, Lake Tahoe’s crystal-clear waters and mountain scenery have made it a year-round destination for both day-trippers from the Bay Area and international visitors. But this alpine jewel is showing serious signs of strain.
Traffic congestion around the lake has become legendary, with summer weekends bringing gridlock on the roads circling the shore. During peak winter weekends, the drive from San Francisco that should take 3.5 hours can stretch to 7 or more.
More troubling is the impact on the lake itself. Tahoe’s famous clarity has been declining steadily, with visibility dropping from nearly 100 feet in the 1970s to less than 70 feet today. Scientists point to stormwater runoff, development, and human impact as major factors.
Housing has become virtually unattainable for locals as second homes and vacation rentals dominate the market. In South Lake Tahoe, over 20% of housing consists of short-term rentals, creating “dark neighborhoods” of empty vacation homes for much of the year.
Where to go instead
Consider Mammoth Lakes, California for a similar alpine lake experience with fewer crowds and excellent outdoor recreation opportunities. For those seeking crystal-clear waters, Crater Lake National Park in Oregon offers an even deeper blue lake in a less developed setting. June Lake, also in the Eastern Sierra, provides a perfect small-town alternative with four alpine lakes, mountain views, and a fraction of Tahoe’s visitors.
4. Oaxaca City, Mexico: Cultural Gem Under Pressure
As Fodor’s 2025 No List highlighted, Oaxaca City is already experiencing significant overtourism impacts. This colonial gem in southern Mexico has become internationally renowned for its vibrant cultural traditions, incredible cuisine, and indigenous crafts.
Since 2020, tourism has increased by a staggering 77%, with visitors from around the world flocking to experience mezcal tastings, Day of the Dead celebrations, and the famous Guelaguetza festival. This surge has fundamentally altered the city’s character.
Local residents report water shortages lasting up to 40 days in some neighborhoods, while tourist accommodations receive regular deliveries. Housing costs have skyrocketed, with the city center increasingly dominated by Airbnbs and boutique hotels that price out locals.
Anti-tourist sentiment has grown, with graffiti reading “Oaxaca is not merchandise” and “out gringos” appearing throughout the historic center. The disconnection between visitors seeking authentic experiences and the commodification of Oaxacan culture has created a mounting tension.
Where to go instead
Try Puebla, another colonial city just a few hours from Mexico City. Puebla offers similar architectural beauty, a rich culinary tradition (it’s the birthplace of mole poblano), and vibrant cultural experiences without the overwhelming tourism pressure. For those seeking indigenous cultural experiences, consider San Cristóbal de las Casas in Chiapas, which offers highland scenery, traditional communities, and historical architecture while maintaining more of its local character.
5. Jackson Hole, Wyoming: Where Wildlife and Wealthy Visitors Collide
Jackson Hole serves as the gateway to Grand Teton and Yellowstone National Parks, making it a magnet for nature lovers. But this once-rustic ranching valley has transformed into an upscale resort destination where billionaires have pushed out millionaires – and ordinary folks have been priced out entirely.
The statistics are staggering: the median home price in Jackson now exceeds $2.5 million, making it impossible for most park employees, service workers, and even professionals like teachers and nurses to live in the community they serve. Many workers commute over Teton Pass from Idaho, a treacherous drive in winter conditions.
Beyond the housing crisis, the environmental impact is concerning. Traffic jams to view wildlife have become common in Grand Teton National Park, creating dangerous conditions for both animals and visitors. Bear jams, bison jams, and wolf jams regularly bring traffic to a standstill, with some visitors leaving their vehicles or approaching wildlife for photos.
The seasonal nature of tourism creates additional strains, with businesses desperate for workers during peak seasons and a ghost town feeling during shoulder seasons.
Where to go instead
Look to Pinedale, Wyoming, just an hour south of Jackson. This authentic mountain town offers access to the stunning Wind River Range, excellent fishing and hiking, and a genuine Western atmosphere without the celebrity spotting and million-dollar boutiques. For a similar experience with even fewer crowds, consider Stanley, Idaho, which provides access to the Sawtooth Mountains, pristine lakes, and world-class outdoor recreation opportunities at a fraction of the cost and congestion.
Finding Balance in Travel And Avoid Overtourism
The challenges facing these destinations highlight a growing tension in tourism: How do we experience extraordinary places without loving them to death? The answer may lie in how we approach travel itself.
By dispersing tourism dollars to emerging destinations, we can help create more sustainable tourism economies while preserving the character of places already at their capacity limits.
As you plan your 2025 adventures, consider these alternatives or look for destinations actively managing tourism through reservation systems, visitor caps, or sustainable initiatives. And remember – sometimes the most memorable travel experiences happen when you step off the beaten path.
What Stays the Same?
While destinations may change, one travel constant remains: the need for convenient airport parking. No matter where your 2025 adventures take you, OneStopParking continues to offer the cheapest parking rates near major airports throughout North America. With their reliable service, you can book last-minute spots to ensure parking at the best price, even during peak travel seasons when airport lots fill up quickly. This budget-friendly option is particularly valuable as more travelers look to maximize their vacation dollars by saving on peripheral expenses like parking.
Are there any emerging destinations you’ve discovered that offer amazing experiences without the crushing crowds? Or have you witnessed overtourism impacts in your favorite places? The conversation about sustainable tourism is just beginning, and your experiences matter in shaping how we travel in the future.